Skip to main content

Strategic Connections: Short-Term Negotiation Tactics for Long-Term Success

Strategic Connections: Short-Term Negotiation Tactics for Long-Term Success

October 29, 2025

Wednesday 1:00 p.m.-2:00 p.m. ET

In the complex world of insurance and risk management, how do you negotiate effectively without compromising long-term relationships? John Burrows, Ph.D., Senior Lecturer at the University of Chicago and Associate Fellow at Oxford University, joined us to explore practical tools and approaches to the ‟negotiator’s dilemma” – knowing when to compete and when to collaborate. He shared real-world examples of successful trust-based bargaining, revealed how network structures impact business resilience and provided actionable strategies to elevate your negotiation skills while developing the relationship capital that drives sustainable success. 

This program is presented as part of the Travelers Institute’s Forces at Work initiative, an educational platform to help today’s leaders navigate the shifting dynamics of the modern workplace and prioritize employees and their well-being. 

Please note: Due to the nature of the replays, survey and chat features mentioned in the webinar recordings below are no longer active.

Watch webinar replay

Listen to the podcast

 Travelers Institute Risk & Resilience podcast logo   
Tune in to “Strategic Connections: Short-Term Negotiation Tactics for Long-Term Success,” available on Apple Podcasts® and Spotify.

Learn more, explore the most recent episodes and subscribe to the Travelers Institute Risk and Resilience podcast.

Summary

What did we learn? Here are the top takeaways from Strategic Connections: Short-Term Negotiation Tactics for Long-Term Success:

Trade on your differences. It’s common to look at negotiations as a zero-sum game with a winner and a loser, or as an exercise in compromise, Burrows said. A better approach is to figure out which items each side values more than the other side does, then work out a deal that takes those preferences into account so everyone at the table ends up in a better position, he said. A good starting point is to consider time, money and quality. “You might want all three, but think about if one or two of those is more important than the other to you,” he said.

Bundle the ask. Present “bundles” of options rather than starting off issue by issue, Burrows said. One example: offering a job candidate a choice between two packages, each with a different location, salary and bonus. This approach subtly reveals your preferences, encourages the other party to do the same and opens the way for trust-building conversations. During the process, you can pay attention to the other party’s emotional reactions to glean data on their priorities, he said. “Through the back-and-forth, you start to build rapport and trust one another,” he said.

Take your time and pause negotiations if necessary. “Our bodies don’t like uncertainty,” Burrows said, noting that this can cause negotiators to rush when they should slow down. “Become more comfortable with ambiguity and uncertainty,” he suggested. Taking your time allows you to build relationships, which are key to successful negotiations. It also helps to prevent mistakes, such as tossing out a number that’s too low due to a feeling of pressure. “It’s OK to pause and ask for a time-out,” he said. “Be prepared to be thrown off but also to not let it derail the negotiation.”

Build a scoring system. One common negotiating mistake is to fixate too much on the hard numbers, Burrows said. “That’s because they’re salient and we can assess whether we’ve won or lost fairly quickly,” he said. Better negotiators recognize this pitfall and get ahead of it by setting up a scoring system that assigns a number or dollar value to each element being negotiated, including the less tangible items, he said. “This way, when you’re weighing one bundle versus another bundle, you actually have the numbers to make an assessment,” he said.

Know the cost of walking away. The most important negotiation terminology is BATNA: best alternative to a negotiated agreement, according to Burrows. “A BATNA is a flashing neon light reminding you what happens if you get up and walk away,” he said. Knowing your BATNA allows you to prepare for a negotiation by improving your walk-away scenario, such as by securing a job offer from a competitor before negotiating with your top-choice employer, he said. It also helps you avoid making a bad deal because you got caught up in the moment. “The goal of negotiating is not to reach just any agreement but to reach one that’s better than you’d get without one,” he said.

Speaker

 
John Burrows, Ph.D.

Senior Lecturer, University of Chicago’s Harris School of Public Policy; Associate Fellow, Oxford University’s Saïd Business School 

Host

Joan Woodward headshot
Joan Woodward
President, Travelers Institute; Executive Vice President, Public Policy, Travelers


Related content

Unlocking Your Potential: Lessons in Leadership and Influence

What is influence and how do we build more of it? Those are the questions behind Laura Cox Kaplan’s weekly podcast, She Said/She Said. Laura joined us to share career and leadership lessons learned from the hundreds of leaders she’s interviewed.

Ripple Effect Leadership: Building High-Trust Teams in a Low-Trust World

Leadership expert Chris Rollins joined us to talk about inclusive leadership, share his Ripple Effect Leadership™ framework and discuss how leading with vulnerability and empathy can transform the workplace.

How to Negotiate Without Fear with Expert Strategist Victoria Medvec

High-stakes negotiation expert Dr. Victoria Medvec shared strategies for increasing your negotiating confidence and tips from her new book, Negotiate Without Fear: Strategies and Tools to Maximize Your Outcomes.

Related news

The art of negotiation: Benchmark, bundle, trade
November 13, 2025 | Carrier Management